Is It Haram to Attend Non-Muslim Funerals?
29 SEP 2017
Whether attending a non-Muslim funeral is haram, or prohibited, is a question that has given rise to significant differences of opinion within the Muslim community. Some Muslim legal scholars assert that attending the funeral of a non-Muslim friend or relative can be wholly consistent with Islamic principles. Others, though, argue that attending a non-Muslim funeral violates core principles of the Islamic faith.
1 Haram and Halal
As Muslim scholar Yusuf al Qaradawi observes, Islamic law divides human behavior into two distinct categories: lawful (halal) or unlawful (haram). Determining whether a particular action is haram is both essential and complex. For example, not only does a funeral raise issues in regard to proper rituals and social ethics, it also has the potential to involve a believer in the worship of a false god. Because committing the sin of shirk, or idolatry, is believed to be worthy of eternal suffering, the implications of attending a non-Muslim funeral can go beyond simple questions of etiquette.
2 Muhammad and the Quran
As Islamic Research Foundation President Zakir Naik notes, a Muslim's answer to this question must be consistent with the Quran and the Sunnah, the legal precedent derived from the Hadith, which are contemporary accounts of Muhammad's statements and actions. For example, as noted in Sayyid Saabik's collection of Islamic law, the Quran (9:113) indicates that it is haram for Muslims to pray for pagans who are clearly condemned to eternal fire, even if they are relatives. On the other hand, the Hadith report that Muhammad once stood up for a passing funeral procession, only to be informed that the deceased was a non-Muslim. Instead of sitting down, Muhammad said, "Does he not also have a soul?"
3 Why Attendance is Permitted
A number of Muslim scholars agree that neither the Quran nor the Sunnah impose an absolute prohibition on attending non-Muslim funerals. According to Grand Mufti of Egypt Ali Gomaa, attending a non-Muslim funeral is in fact consistent with the ethics of the Quran (60:8), which commands believers not to cut themselves off from non-Muslims who are not fighting against them. In addition to expressing good manners in a way that attracts non-believers to Islam, Muslims can avoid jeopardizing their own spiritual state by making sure that they do not participate in shirk or other prohibited behavior at any non-Muslim funerals they attend, such as praying for deceased individuals who had worshipped gods other than the one true God of Islam.
4 Why Attendance is Forbidden
Some Muslim religious authorities prohibit attending non-Muslim funerals. For instance, Sheikh Sulaymaan ibn Naasir al-‘Alwaan asserts that the Quran teaches that attending a non-Muslim funeral is haram because it shows love, respect or friendship toward an unbeliever, which he argues is forbidden by the Quran (58:22). Similarly, a fatwa, or ruling on Islamic law, published on Islam Web cites the Quran's prohibition on praying for deceased non-believers as grounds for banning attendance at their funerals. The same fatwa notes that attending a Hindu cremation ceremony would be an even greater violation of Islamic law, since it would imply agreement with the burning of a body, which is also haram. Nonetheless, there are also Islamic scholars who make an exception for funerals of non-Muslims with whom a believer has some sort of personal connection, such as a co-worker or relative.
- 1 Youtube: Dr. Zakir Naik - Can a Muslim Attend Non Muslim Celebration or Funeral ?
- 2 Islam Web: Fatwa 90625 - Attending the Crematorium of a Hindu Colleague
- 3 Islam Question and Answer: Attending the Funeral of a Non-Muslim Colleague in the Church Out of Respect for the Deceased
- 4 Yusuf Al-Qardawi; The Lawful and the Prohibited in Islam