Search for...

How to Compare & Contrast "West Side Story" to "Romeo and Juliet"

by Josh Patrick, Demand Media

    Great art borrows from the past and gives to the future. Therefore, one way to learn more about works of art is to compare and contrast them. This allows you to see the works as individual parts of a larger whole. The play "Romeo and Juliet" by William Shakespeare was written around the year 1595. "West Side Story" is a musical adapted from Shakespeare's play and was first performed in 1957. Both are stories of unrequited love that end tragically, but there are many elements that make them very different. Exploring the similarities and differences is a rewarding exercise into quality literature.

    Items you will need

    • Text of "Romeo and Juliet"
    • Recording or text of "West Side Story"
    • Pen or pencil
    • Notepad
    Step 1

    Read "Romeo and Juliet" carefully. Pay attention to the themes, which are the big picture ideas that hold the play together.

    Step 2

    Make a character list and general plot outline for "Romeo and Juliet." Think of what adjectives best describe the characters and write these down for each one.

    Step 3

    Watch a filmed production of "West Side Story" or read the text. Make a mental note of the big ideas and a character list. Begin thinking about how the two works compare to each other.

    Step 4

    Compare the plots first. The stories begin in the same way, with a fight. Both conclude with tragedy. Determine how else the plays are similar, and also how the stories depart from each other.

    Step 5

    Compare and contrast the settings. On the surface, the plays couldn't be more different. "Romeo and Juliet" takes place in medieval Italy, while "West Side Story" is set in New York City. Look past the obvious differences and see if there aren't ways in which the stories are similar.

    Step 6

    Compare the characters in the stories. Determine which ones are intended to be mirrors of each other. For example, Tony in "West Side Story" and Romeo in "Romeo and Juliet" fulfill the same role as the young man in love.

    Step 7

    Notice the characters that seem to be unique to each story and what each contributes. Also, notice how even the characters that are very similar have attributes that make them distinct.

    Step 8

    Compare the themes of "Romeo and Juliet" with "West Side Story." Both plays deal with young love and the forces that act against that love. Both deal with loyalty and violence. Determine how each of these stories resolves the main conflict.

    Style Your World With Color

    Tip

    • The language of Shakespeare can be difficult. It was meant to be performed, so reading the text aloud can help you understand the more difficult passages. Your library probably has a film of a "Romeo and Juliet" performance. It could be helpful to see the action in addition to reading it.

    About the Author

    Josh Patrick has several years of teaching and training experience, both in the academy and the private sector. He presented original work at the 20th Century Literature Conference in Louisville, Kentucky. Patrick worked for three years on the editorial board for "Inscape," his alma mater's literary magazine. He holds a Master of Library and Information Science.

    Photo Credits

    • Comstock/Comstock/Getty Images

    Watch An Education Video!